@Poloplayer 6.5-7.0 is fine, in fact I believe that’s the range doctors prefer to stop lows. I used to be 6.4% for a while and I was happy at that and I probably would still be happy with that. With a Dexcom and the alerts that allow me to adjust highs or lows easier it was easy to drop my percentage without doing anything different other than responding faster to changes.
Type one 42 years. MDI.
Range: 4.0 to 6.1 100%
Complications have been shown to start from > 6.1.mmol. You can have normal bloodsugars without having hypos, you wouldn’t know it because your not taught how or shown better. Doctors would have you suffering painful complications. I should know, im trying to undo all the ones ive collected, like autonomic neuropathy of the vagus nerve.
@Edward2 There is some talk about 6.5% not having complications from that level of A1C. And while I have aimed lower I’m not sure there is enough proof that the lower A1C’s are better than the 6.5-7.0% range.
Here is an article from Sept/2019 from a study released last August.
And if someone is happy with that range and it helps keep them from to lows, then for them it’s better and I’m not sure there is enough research out there to say they are wrong.
So good to see your excellent results over an extended period of time. I would love to be vegan but love fish too much. I also consume some dairy and occasionally eggs. But for the most part my diet is vegan since I limit it to a ton of vegetables, tofu, other soy products, soy milk, a limited amount of fruits and some amounts of carbs. I am still in the experimental phase of all of this. I have had diabetes for over 47 years with no complications. I attribute this to my activity level, choosing not to eat things just because they would taste good such as excessive carbs and the amazing advances in treatment, such as the availability of insulin pumps and
CGMs. Keep us all up to date on your continued progress. Way to go!!!
I appreciate your input. I actually tried the cgm, but have not been successful in keeping it place. I exercise to the extreme, daily, therefore perspiring a lot. I can keep my pump site in, but not the cgm. I, personally, never wanted to wear anything extra, so I feel my success (this far,) is sufficient. I am a
competitive bodybuilder, as well, so I hide my pump sites, anyway. I know I’d be better off with cgm technology, but hope I wont need it until it is small enough to be easily implanted! Lol
I would take the “No Benefit Found for HbA1c Below 6.5% in Type 1 Diabetes” study with a grain of salt. Quote from the article: “The findings, from more than 10,000 children and adults with type 1 diabetes diagnosed between 1998 and 2017 …”. None of the subjects had diabetes for more than 20 years. I developed complications after 25 years. My A1C typically was 6.2%. I will be dead by the time a study comes out that covers a lifetime of diabetes. Trying hard to keep my BG as normal as possible does seem like a reasonable insurance policy. My complications provide motivation that I was lacking before.
@Helmut I agree probably lower is probably better, we all know the doctors are paranoid about lows and you really can bend stats to whatever result you want out of it.
I just think that someone that is within the 6.5-7.0% range might be okay in the scheme of things and that if they are happy with that range and it keeps them out of hypo’s that they can be okay with that. And most doctors will tell their patients to aim for under 7%.
But for those that can and still keep good control, lower is probably better.
A1C for most diabetics is just a number. It does not reflect the highs and lows that got them there and unless they are having their A1C performed by a lab that has their equipment regularly tested and certified, the A1C these patients are getting is only accurate within .5%. If a person is on a Dexcom CGM, comparing Glucose Management Indicator, although not perfect either, will be a much more accurate comparison to another patient also on a Dexcom. Then there is the Standard Deviation which is just as important.
@Marie20, I have no idea whether 6.5-7.0% is ok for everybody else. It was definitely not ok for me. I don’t fault doctors for being paranoid about lows. I am trying to go as low as I can while minimizing severe lows. How did I come up with a number? I figured that I wanted to stay 2 standard deviations away from a severe low. My SD is 20. 55+2 *20=95. Thus I am shooting for an average BG of 95 and I am right there. When I was on MDI without CGM my SD was 50. It would have been irresponsible to attempt 95 at that time. 55+2*50=155. I ran my A1C much lower than that and had quite a lot of severe lows.
It’s good for people to hear what wasn’t okay for them and what standard deviation even is. I didn’t have a clue about what it was before my first CGM.
I’m glad your diet is working so well for you. Thanks for posting!
I am not vegan, but my diet is fairly close out of necessity, as I can’t eat dairy or eggs, can’t eat most processed meat, and choose not to eat much red meat. So I eat chicken and fish and otherwise vegan (I do eat things like gelatin on occasion).
I am still striving for control as good as yours!
Just wanted to add the last couple of weeks.
And of course I prefer the more 100% graph I keep on my phone to look at, it always makes me happier! But it is for 65-160 daytime range versus the 65-140 that’s above.
My A1C was 5.1% on 11/6!
I knew it would be lower, but I was expecting the 5.7-5.9% range. A combo of lower or no DP for the last few months. Although it can’t make up it’s mind completely!
Fantastic. I had a feeling that the many 100% days would translate into a good A1C.
That is great Marie!! Good for you!
I had my endo appointment today!
I took her my reports. All the Clarity reports of 14 days which she requests, but I also took her 30 and 90 day summaries to show I’ve been at 99% in range of 65-160 during the day and 65-180 at night! Less than 1% of any high or lows combined. I did not want her to question my 5.1% A1C.
The first thing she said was well I see you are lower and she looked at my reports sitting there and on the first page I had the summary of 99% time in range. And she said it looks like it belongs on the cover of a magazine. You have really good control.
This is very good! It looks like a normal persons!
So great Marie!! This vegan had an A1c run this morning and it was 5.2. We rock this way of eating!
BTeach me your ways! My BGs and insulin sensitivity definitely benefit from this WOE, but I struggle with finding meal options and keeping weight up since this WOE is generally lower calorie than others.
I’d appreciate any tips!
Rwaz, not sure if you are asking Marie or me, but since you have really increased your insulin sensitivity I assume you are eating very low fat. Both ways of eating are very good, but I will tell you the kinds of foods I eat. Most everything I eat is made from scratch with unprocessed organic foods.
My husband and I cook large pots of food and eat them for several nights. Examples of what we eat are recipes like
- Sweet Potato Dal
- Chana Saag- A North Indian spinach dish with chickpeas.
- Skillet Refried Beans- no fat with rice
- Indian Spiced Chickpeas and Kale
Those dishes are from Everyday Happy Herbivore
- Minestrone Soup/Stew with potatoes and pasta.
- Pumpkin Chili
- Potato Leek Soup
- Sweet Potato Squash and Black Bean Enchiladas
These are from Thug Kitchen Eat Like You Give a - - - -.
My husband can’t digest beans well so he eats a lot of sweet potatoes since he really likes them and of course salads , vegetables and fruit.
We use no oils of any kind. We do use flavored balsamic vinegars.
I eat several Garbanzo Bean Chocolate Cookies every day. If interested I will post the recipe.
There are lots of good vegan cookbooks out now. Most use more fat than I like, but it is easy to substitute broth for oil to cook vegetables for example.
In the summer we eat large salads with beans etc.
If you are losing too much weight you might not be eating enough. I lost 10 lbs at first, but stay right where I should weigh most of the time. You can eat a lot of food with this woe.
Recently I have added a few walnuts to my bowl of oats grouts and fruit in the morning. I also have started eating a few low fat rice crackers and half of a low fat pita once in a while.
My husband likes to freeze bananas and flavorings and put them in the blender to make a bowl of ice cream.
We use a lot of nutritional yeast, pumpkin seeds and pumpkin seed kernels.
Hope this helps a little bit.
Hi @Rwaz I eat what I want. But I am retired so I don’t actually eat a lot.
A newer site I really like that has some easy and delicious recipes!
Sign up for her free e-mails to get new recipes every week.
(The toasted tofu cubes coated in nutritional yeast and then baked is really good and easy! Great to snack on or add to dishes)
To stop weight loss you have to add more calories of course. If you are not low fat, it’s easier with some fats. Avocados, nuts (guacamole, pates etc). The other way to add more calories is adding extra shakes, make sure they are extra and not a substitute for eating, they can be nutrient dense.
I do a lot of veggie bowls. I like easy, so I will take a bag of frozen mixed veggies and add either seitan, tofu, tempeh or a fake meat. Then I will add either gravy, parmegan (nuts and nutritional yeast powder) Braggs aminos, vegan cheese etc to change it up. What I don’t finish makes a great easy grab snack.
Today I had a large veggie bowl, pineapple and a cookie, some crackers with vegan herb cream cheese, soymilk and cashews. Yesterday I had Baked Beans with fake hot dogs, A fake bologna sandwich on an english muffin with some leftover stir fried veggies. I already spotted the veggie meatballs in the freezer and will probably have those with spaghetti tomorrow. I also have some fresh green beans and asparagus to cook from the farmers market and another pineapple to cut up.
I seem to thrive on my mixed veggie bowls and I love the fake meats, Gardein, Beyond Meat, Sweet Earth, Tofurky, Yves etc. Whether it be mixed in with a dish, deli slices for a sandwich or stand alone as a snack.
As for controlling my BG’s. It’s all in the dosing.
Regular meals I do half my dose a half hour before I eat and the rest when I eat. That way if I don’t finish or add I can adjust the second dose. If it’s a higher fat item I have a tendency to take a dose when I eat and the other half a half hour later. But you have to learn which foods you need to do what with. Some foods could even be 1/3, 1/3, 1/3. Like my veggie pizza.
Prebolus timing is the first big key to keeping my numbers even and not spiking too high…
The second huge thing is my CGM, I have a Dexcom and I tightened my parameters of alerts. I have mine set at 80-130. 80 lets me know I am dropping to much for me and I usually grab a couple of chunks of pineapple or some lemonade, oj etc to level out. A small amount so I don’t turn around and go too high. The 130 allows me to get on my exercise bike to stall a rise until my insulin kicks in enough. Proper dosing though means I usually stay under 140.
When I started with my CGM I just had it set for too high or too low. Meaning once it alerted it was already too late. I figured out that setting the alerts in time for adjustments worked out better, and then the next thing I did is too tighten up those alerts. So say my first settings were 65 or 180, next I changed to 65 to 70 or 75 and then to 80. My 180 got changed to 170 then 160 , 150, 140, 130. That slower change also allowed me to get used to the narrower settings.
The third help is my pump, it allows me to give those small adjustments that I just wasn’t as likely to do before as easily.
I use about 50-55 units total insulin, about 25 is basal and 25-30 bolus for the day. That’s a huge change from when I was on MDI.