schleima - I sympathize with your frustration that the Dexcom software has been programmed to not believe your calibration values when quite different from the most recent G6 reading.
It is natural to get frustrated – Dexcom could and should have done better. Blood Glucose meters using test strips have been refined to be quite accurate, and the software should just believe you. But it is what it is.
I mostly run into the problem you describe during the 1st 24 hours of a new sensor – not all the time, thankfully.
I appreciate the tricks people have described, basically to not shock the software with a calibration value that is hugely different from the most recent G6 value. It as if we need to be sure not to offend the persona in that software.
Since I am able to get fairly inexpensive test strips, and when my meter calibration value causes my receiver or app to reject my calibration and more or less shuts down, I just switch to depending on my meter for as long as it takes to convince the Dexcom software it is wrong and my meter is right. Sure, this might be 20 minutes or 2 hours, but I just will not let myself get frustrated, since the meter allows me to manage my glucose levels while Dexcom is down.
I am ok with all this because most of the time, my G6 is reasonably accurate, typically on days 2-10 of a new sensor. And having a good CGM like the G6 is so wonderful, that these occasional problems are ok with me.
I happen to use Medicare for insurance, and I find it strange that they will not pay for BG meter test strips when they fund the Dexcom G6. I could not use the G6, at least during the 1st 24 hours of a new sensor, without a BG meter. Luckily, I use a meter for which accurate 3rd-party affordable test strips are available, so I am quick to let the meter take over if the G6 software goes funny.
By the way, there are times the underlying problem is the sensor did not get installed correctly or the sensor wire has been pulled out, maybe while sleeping – in other words, sometimes, the software is right that something is wrong. In those cases, switching to a new sensor is probably the only solution.
These new technologies are so, so much better than what was available just 10 years ago, that I think we just need to tolerate the idiosyncrasies while enjoying the huge benefits.