They actually do ask to see my logs, and they also look at the downloads I've done from my pump and my dexcom. They also do a pump download. I tell myself it is because I am a fairly new patient to them (I was with my former Endo practice for about 25 years). When I realized that I was somewhat "suspect" (the only word I could come up with) I did the handwritten log as well. It's been years but I have gotten into the habit. I like the "My Other Checkbook" ones from the Diabetes Mall. Too many logs have space for only 4 tests a day - which is rather useless (in my very opinionated opinion). It is also become a good way for me to lose a few pounds: I ask if it is worth writing down, and usually the snack isn't!
You got the impression from them that you're "suspect"? It seems like your A1c would immediately negate all of that. Unless you feel like keeping detailed logs is improving your control I'd be inclined to tell them you don't need any logs and they're free to download the Dexcom at any time.
Well I think they are operating under assumptions that 1) no one tests as often as I do, thus no one does the micro-bolusing I bother with, 2) a good A1C is only from a mix of extreme and dangerous lows and inevitable highs (and yes I do have rogue numbers but I deal with them straight away) and 3) I must be the most anal person they've ever met. Currently they aren't equipped to download the Dexcom.
Jim, thank you for sharing your story. it gives me hope!