It really is a matter of what works best for you. If you are happy with MDI and doing well on it just stay with it. MDI is alot cheaper.
I was on mdi for the first year and a half and it was a nightmare for me-my blood sugar was very unstable I was having terrible lows etc.
Eventually I switched to the pump and it was much better for me. It is a lot of work though, it allows me to treat bad lows that I could not treat on MDI because of the long acting basil. On the pump I can just shut off the insulin for lows and that helps me treat it. I can also increase or lower my basal rate anytime. I really need to be able to do that because my blood sugar goes all over the place, rapidly a lot of the time.
I also have a lot of problems with irritation from the insets and stuff like that. But I live with it because it’s much better for me to manage the blood sugar. I also cannot wear dresses anymore because I wear it on the belt around my waist and there’s no way to do that and not have it look really bizarre, I can only wear it around my waist I’ve tried putting it in pants pockets and it just falls out so it’s not safe. I can’t stick it in my bra the way some women do because it’s going to be uncomfortable and obvious etc. my pump has tubing so I have to always be aware of that because it gets caught on things.
the bad part about the pump is it’s much easier to go into DKA if you are type one and I go into it very easily and at not very high blood sugar. It is still much much better than MDI for me.
You need to have a back up long-acting in case your pump fails as well. I just went through that again where the pump lost all of the records and they sent me the wrong pumps, yes multiples, lol, one of them failed again, finally I got one that works lol- but it did take a few days and it was upsetting and frustrating. Fortunately the original one was still delivering insulin so I was able to keep using that and they finally got me one that works.
On MDI I injected myself with the wrong insulin at least once, that is really a danger. I found with the pens there was still after many years no good way of really keeping a record of whether you did your basal or not- I had to split my basal and the often could not remember if I had injected it or not. It’s actually much easier to overdose yourself on MDI especially if you use the fast acting instead of the basal- you could really get yourself into trouble if you’re insulin sensitive. On my pump I can set a maximum bolus which is four units for me so it would be very hard for me to overdose myself bolusing for food. I would have to do 2 4 unit boluses without realizing it.
My pump keeps all the records so I don’t have to write anything down anymore. I can look at it anytime and see what’s going on. Like what my lastbolus was and when and I can set a duration for how long iob is active which is 4 hours generally for me.
It’s annoying and it has alarms on it but still much better for me- it’s the only thing that really works.
If you use Dexcom and you have a Tslim, you could set it up to have your blood sugar on your pump and or or you can have it control some of the basal insulin delivery. I don’t do that because Dexcom is sometimes very innacurate for me. I really need the Dexcom as well, basically I would have no quality of life without it and maybe die from a low. But I use it with my receiver and my phone, not my pump.
I would like to try to use an Omni pod at some point just to see what it’s like not to have the tubing. I don’t know how well it would work for me though because with Tandem you can do very small doses which I need often, you can do a lot of good stuff with it. That would have to be an additional pump that I would only use when I wanna swim or wear a dress or whatever I don’t know if I really will ever be able to do that cause I’m not in in a position to be able to afford two pumps now and I don’t think my insurance will cover it.
Going to the beach is the worst and I hardly ever do it now because it’s such a hassle because I’m worried- it’s hot, you have to take your pump off and hide it somewhere to swim etc. and it’s just very stressful and unpleasant. So when I go it is mostly for walks and wading etc.